Ten years ago, I sat by myself on a fourth-hand futon and watched the television. It was a bit strange – to watch history unravel by myself – and also strange because I had recently moved into the Blob. It was an “intentional Christian community” in Centretown, Ottawa. (We tried to avoid the word commune hence the adjectives and quotations marks.) There were usually others around the place, but that morning I had the Blob to myself. It was a sunny apartment, taking up the top two floors on an old hotel, and overlooking a busy and interesting intersection. I’d started breakfast, planning to head outside soon and do some job hunting, but the CBC slowed me down. The radio was on in the kitchen, and, as I ate my granola, I listened to the hosts make their first tentative descriptions of what would be an impossible day.
By the time I turned on the TV, my mother was on the phone. She wanted me out of downtown.
“This is Ottawa, Mum. I’m fine.”
But she didn’t listen. I was downtown in a capital city, only ten minutes walk from Parliament Hill, and who knew how much of the sky was crumbling. She said she was going to pack my visiting grandmother into the car and come in from the suburbs to collect me. The rest of my siblings were safely ensconced in small and obscure Ontario towns, well away from office towers. Kidnapping me from Centretown was her one possible maternal act of world-saving that morning.
And I appreciated it. I was worried. Not about Ottawa. But I knew people in New York – a former housemate of mine, the sister of a friend, a one-time owner of the Blob’s futon. This wasn’t an anonymous catastrophe. Everyone knew someone in New York.
By lunchtime, I was sitting with my Mum and my Gran in the Arrow and Loon down Bank Street. Heading back out to the suburbs felt extreme, but at least Parliament was a little further way. There was, of course, a television on in the pub. My Gran was getting agitated about the analytical coverage. I can see her point. In the thick of World War II, when she was doing her feisty best to raise a family on her own while her soldier husband was away, the country was plastered with government issued signs highlighting the risks of indiscretion. Now, there were governmental figures on the television speaking all-too openly about military assets and tactics. Times change.
Now, ten years on, my Gran has passed away, and I have a five year old daughter. She hasn’t asked any questions about 9/11. It isn’t something on her radar. This feels a little strange – that history has happened so recently, and she doesn’t know it. But I’m glad she doesn’t yet. Five feels so little. And I’m sure when the questions do come, I’ll be saying ten feels so little. Fifteen feels little.
But history does break it. When we arrived in Edinburgh last week, Beangirl was quick to notice the shop next door to our house, its windows boarded up for renovation.
“Oh no! Not in Edinburgh, too.”
We assured her that this wasn’t because of riots. She wasn’t sure. She’d seen windows like this before. They meant that there were more police on the streets and the shops all close early. It meant adults were scared.
But now, a few days on, she and Blue have shifted their interest to the graffiti rather than the boards – they are particularly fond of two grinning skeletons. They call them dubbed Robbie and Crusoe.
We all have ways of dealing with history.







Another aspect of that day at the Blob was the discussion that evening. Dispite all being Christians trying to live out our faith, there was a variety of reactions. One wanted to immidiately bomb the attackers into oblivion. Another, a Mennonite, was adamant that violence is never an answer. I suspect the rest were somewhat stunned and trying to reason it all out.
[Reply]
Stunned is a good word for that night. I think the violent reaction is also a manifestation of that stunned status. But it was good to sit down together then, even if we couldn’t all agree. Maybe especially.
[Reply]
Over the past week I slowly watched a two hour retrospective on the events of 9/11 and the aftermath. It featured documentary footage shot by two French film makers, a pair of brothers, who happened to be in NY only blocks away from the WTC making a documentary on becoming a NYC fire fighter. Peanut saw a few minutes of it, saw the first plane hit Tower 2 and exclaimed, “Uh oh! What happened?! It’s broken! FIRE!!” And that was the last she saw of it. I watched the rest of it in fits and starts when she was sleeping. 3 is just too young to understand the nuances of such an event. 31 is too young. As I said to J: “I know that it happened but I still can’t believe it. It just doesn’t fit in my head.”
[Reply]
As an American living in Canada I am always subject to the subtle and not so subtle anti-Americanism I encounter. September 11th temporarily silenced that. For a time (weeks even) their was nothing but love and respect given to me by my Canadian brothers and sisters. Each year that love and care returns; if only for a few days. It is a nice feeling – solidarity. But all the pomp is in my mind, too high a price to pay. Remember the attack yes but lets keep perspective here. Don’t feel too sorry for one of if not still the most powerful and prosperous nation on earth. Nearly 3000 people died that day and they deserve to be remembered. But 3000 people died today just from malaria. 3000 more died the day before that and 3000 more will die tomorrow as well… and on… and on. If as a people we truly care about the lives lost on September 11th then let us show it; not with a moment of silence or by watching tributes on television but by doing what we can to save the lives of others being needlessly lost each day.
[Reply]
Katie Munnik Reply:
September 23rd, 2011 at 4:34 am
You’re right – there is so much ongoing loss and suffering throughout the world that it does seem strange to look back ten years in order to mourn and to wonder.
But I think that remembering September 11th is important, because it was such a strong and sudden reminder of human brokenness. The scale of violence shocked us. That it was caused by divisions between peoples didn’t.
In remembering September 11th 2001, we aren’t just mourning the dead – we are, I hope, mourning the human brokenness that causes this kind of human violence. And you’re right – pomp gets in the way here. Because we are all implicated in human brokenness. We are not all guilty, but we are implicated.
[Reply]